patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Millage Vote Could Mean More School Trips to DIA

Bloomfield Hills Schools students could benefit from Tuesday's millage approval along with art lovers.

 

 

Oakland County residents on Tuesday authorized an Art Institute Authority millage that is reported to cost residents $15 a year on a house worth $150,000. In return for this investment, the Detroit Institute of Arts (DIA) will provide free, unlimited general admission for residents and free field trips for students.

Shira Good, spokeswoman for the Bloomfield Hills Schools, said she asked instructional staff about field trips following Tuesday's vote, but that it was too soon to know.

"It’s pretty soon to tell about how this will impact us," she wrote in an e-mail to Patch. "I know we’re thrilled with the outcome and are pleased that such a treasure in our area will be preserved."

Last year, a combined 842 students, teachers, and chaperones from six different buildings (Bloomfield Hills Middle School, East Hills Middle School, West Hills Middle School, Lahser High School, International Academy, and Model High School) in the district visited the institute, said DIA spokeswoman Pamela Marcil.

The DIA also provided the following breakdown of students from Bloomfield-area private schools that also visited last year (all counts include students, teachers, and chaperones):

Marcil also said that it was too early to tell if requests for field trips would increase, but noted several special exhibitions that should attract residents and students from the tri-county area for free. The millage barely passed in Macomb County, but was widely supported by more than 60 percent of voters in both Oakland and Wayne counties, unofficial results show.

Roughly 71 percent of voters in both Bloomfield Hills and Bloomfield Township supported the measure Tuesday.

For more on this Topic:

Related Topics: Art, Bloomfield Hills Schools, DIA Millage, Field Trips, and Schools
Would you like to see more field trips planned after the DIA millage passed? Tell us in the comments.

Isaac Barr MD

9:17 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

81% of 1900 employees at the water department lost their jobs in detroit yesterday. Police in Detroit is under powered. Detroit could have used the 4,5 million dollars better than allowing kids to visit the museum as much as I favor it. But the money should come from rich Bloomfield Hills Schools not from the unfortunate millage. It still will be costly having to transport the students, teachers accompany them, park the bus and have the driver wait. The entry fee to DIA is the smallest part of cost to visit DIA. If Detroit goes into bunkrapcy all the DIA millage money can find it's way to Detroit treasury which owns the DIA. As Nancy Pelosy said: "now that you have it you will find what is in it". After all the word DIA is not mentioned in the millage language for which you voted and it is "Art Authority" not DIA "Authority" which means that new millage proposal for any of 22 Detroit institutions are in line for the zoo millage style.

Reply

Neal Charness

2:05 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Dr. Baar: It's enough with your "rich Bloomfield Hills Schools" diatribe. Your perpetual misrepresentations (and incorrect spellings) don't led credibility to what you say. Our rich schools probably offer remedial spelling for adult residents. You are an embarassment to our local community and the area at large. It's not that I disagree with you, we're all entitled to our opinions. However, your statements and allegations go beyond opinions and become accusations.

Reply

Elizabeth

5:07 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Dr. Barr,

My high school student was one of the 842 Bloomfield Hills students to visit the DIA last school year. Please note that the cost of visiting the DIA, including transportation, is placed on the students or parents of the students, NOT the district. That cost was in addition to the DIA membership fee I had already paid.

From reading your comment, it sounds like you would rather have the Bloomfield Hills School District provide $$ to the City of Detroit rather than Oakland County tax payers paying a millage to support the operations of the DIA. Your logic is unintelligible. You would have been better to simply criticize the milliage itself.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Isaac Barr MD

7:55 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

I made my opinion clear regarding finances of The DIA in the past. My criticism is in good faith regardless of my spelling errors. Let us talk about facts. I am not opposed to the DIA. I was opposed to it's money management. I am a member in the DIA for more than 30 years and donated plenty. 3 children and 3 grand children graduated from Andover and I endorsed DIA field trips always. I want an answer to my concerns. I find that people who decide to settle issues by abuse of those who dare to ask questions have to take a class in civility. Who should pay for DIA visits? Michigan per student funding in Bloomfield Hills Schools is $12.443/student/year, Pontiac schools $7.491, Detroit $7.600. Berkley $8.197. In other words, BHS get more money than any school district in Michigan. This is why BHS are the richest in Michigan. The 842 students of BHS got $10.477.006 while Pontiac kids on the border of Bloomfield Hills and got $6.307.442 or 40% less than BHS students. If one talks about fairness, why should all students of Michigan not have the same opportunities regardless of the property taxes that their parents pay? The DIA should pay to transport the kids from all over the state to the gem museum. They are getting 23 million dollars per year on top of their investments revenue of about 30 million dollars annually, about 55 million dollars per year..

Ken Jackson

8:37 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Mr. Barr,
It is a shame that you feel you are the victim of some kind of abuse. If you are on the receiving end of some nasty words that is perhaps because you have in several missives charged people falsely with crimes -- including the BHS schoolboard and administration and the administration of the DIA. You call them stupid and you call them uninformed. And these are your neighbors or fellow community members. I invite any reader of Patch to search your recorded statements. Your rhetoric is routinely overheated and, consequently, not persuasive to most (although those with a strict anti-tax agenda will always chime in for support). You told neighbors who voted differntly than you on the school bond issue that they were guilty of "crimes against children." I would like to belief you are arguing in good faith but your words undermine that claim. Here you seem to plea for "fairness" in public education. But I can't quite believe the man who charged his Bloomfield neighbors living in "small houses" were taking advantage of homeowners who have been in the district longer is now concerned about the children of Pontiac. You don't like taxes of any kind. That's fine. Argue your point -- but please stop insulting people and wrongly accusing them in writing. And don't be surprised when you join any kind of public discussion about BHS you will get a strong response.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Isaac Barr MD

12:17 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

I never accused anybody of anything. I presented my opinion and alternative priorities for our community. No answer was given to my concerns. Only mud slings and when I was allowed to talk it was under duress. Talk about facts please and leave my person alone. Yes, I believe that in two millages BHSD and Tri County residents were not informed. How can a private citizen compete with millions of dollars invested on advertising by BHS and DIA? I have no personal interest in neither of the millages except that I applied my personal experience as a teacher in Wayne and UM and studying modern education in what I think is good by global criteria (PISA) for our kids. We had never a discussion about future of education. My children and grand children already graduated from Andover. I spelled my opinion clearly: I believe that property tax is not "progressive". There are many of your neighbors who have big houses and are retirees, unemployed or old, empty nesters who struggle with higher taxes. Yet, we wanted a longer school year, better teacher training and starting education in a younger age group. With this agenda the millage would have passed by almost 100% support. What is wrong with that? Regarding the DIA we believe that the community has different priorities. What is more important a museum or police? What is wrong with raising the issue? You have no answers and thus you attack my person and specifically misspell my name. I demand respect. This is my last communication.

Neal Charness

11:08 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Having read too many of Dr. Baar's comments, allegations, and accusations it seems an exercise in fantasy to actually think he acts in "good faith." He is akin to a bank robber who thought, in good faith, that the bank was just holding his money for him.

Reply

Neal Charness

1:06 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Mr. Baar you made accusations against the school board that are patently false. You whine about higher taxes when everyone's have gone down. "Millions of dallars invested in advertising by BHS and DIA." You know that's false. Based on your actions, falsehoods, and behavior (e.g. using the tragic death of a youngster to vent against the school district) YOU HAVE NOT EARNED ANY RESPECT. You are an embarassment to the community.

Reply

Neal Charness

2:04 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012

I must confess to having mispelled your name for months,never noticing it. It was not intentional and I sincerely apologize. I completely stand by my remarks but did not intend to use an incorrect spelling of your name. You said "millions" regarding advertising by BHS and DIA. Here's an opportunity to substantiate your claim or be regarded as someone posting false statements and then claiming it's opinion.

Reply

Ken Jackson

7:56 am on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

"We are angry because of the deception that is on going concealing facts and misrepresenting. We are angry because BHSEB gave public money for propaganda including possible financing, directly or indirectly to One Bloomfield United." Here is a fact, Mr. Barr. These are your words. It is utterly absurd for you claim attacks on "your person" and to be thin skinned about somebody not spelling your name correctly when you are willing -- without evidence -- to charge others with crimes and then have the audacity to insist they respond to your concerns.

Reply

Leave a comment