.
Feedback

OPINION: Why I'm Voting 'Yes'

Funding the high school merger plan on May 8 will take a degree of trust in the BHS school board and administration. They've earned it.

 

We are at this crossroad for for many reasons. These include:

  • Declining student population
  • Aging buildings
  • Higher costs
  • Increasing educational demands
  • Anxiety over Taxes, and
  • Distrust of government institutions in general and our past School Board in particular

Educational excellence is what makes this district a state and national benchmark to which other districts aspire. The hybrid high school will provide the flexibility that future educational challenges will demand. The administration is also confident that the larger building will maintain the small school advantages that we all desire while eliminating the problems that are inherent in the 2 mile bus ride between buildings.


We also need the fiscal responsibility to address the very tough economic realities that are facing all school districts in the state including ours. After participating in most of the Community Partnership Committees over the past year, I am confident that we are up to this challenge. This high school proposal is easily affordable by the school district, being well below the borrowing limit set for us by the State of Michigan, and by the taxpayer, representing only 3% of our annual property tax bill. This plan is a critical step towards addressing the deficits that are potentially ahead of us.

Does this take a degree of trust in the school board and administration? Sure. Do I think they are worthy of that trust? After working one-on-one with many of them for a year, the answer is absolutely!

This is why I’m voting YES on May 8th.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Bloomfield-Bloomfield Hills Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Ken Jackson May 2, 2012 at 11:41 am
Mr. Baron,
Thank you for this and for all your help in clarifying many of the issues about May 8th, particularly those involving the supposed "debt." Your claim that we are at a crossroads here is spot on. And your list of reasons is pretty much comprehensive. I would only add one point about the larger context that makes this such a momentous vote. State funding and support of Public Education has changed dramatically (I hear a lot about Birmingham schools -- as far as I am concerned they are ahead of us only in that they have made this clearer to the community at large). Local communities need to act, and act in the way they have not since the late 19th century if they want to maintain and develop their school districts. At the moment, I trust our administration and school board far more than the state legislature that is -- even as we struggle to agree over an affordable and reasonable plan -- pushing 200 million dollars toward for profit "cyber schools" for K-12. VOTE YES on May 8th.
Elizabeth 123 May 2, 2012 at 11:54 am
Well said Howard.
Amy Cardin May 2, 2012 at 04:16 pm
Howard,
I know you studied long and hard all the information regarding the proposal before us. I know your yes vote is not a knee jerk reaction but was arrived at after exhaustive fact finding, listening and number crunching. I for one appreciate your hard work and the hours you have dedicated to our district and ultimately our students. Thanks for your support! Chris, I too was in Andover yesterday and the room where I was working was ice cold. The hallways were hot. Great would not be a word I would use to describe how it looked. This proposal is needed. This proposal will allow for annual cost savings that will be funneled back into the classrooms. This proposal will facilitate delivery of a world class education. This proposal will improve property values. I believe it is a WIN from every angle. Vote YES on May 8 for a unified high school facility that our district, students and staff can be proud of! Go Black Hawks!
Paul Scheidemantel May 2, 2012 at 05:15 pm
Chris -- I trust that your Andover visit didn't include the auditorium. I was in it a month or so ago for a Bloomfield Booster Board meeting and "great" is not how I would expect anyone to describe it. And, how is the hearsay from an unnamed source that you offer helpful to a fair discussion?
R Gibson May 2, 2012 at 05:39 pm
Mr. Scheidemantel; I sat in that theater for orientation in 1980, it was brand new. I worked the stage crew until I graduated in 1983. The facility has not been taken care of. However, I don't think it is ready to be dozed. It will accept a fly system right now, yes the board and lighting system need to be updated. New seats? Yup. But I don't think the entire thing needs to be destroyed. The pool is in the same shape. Do we need 12 lanes? I don't know. But all the records that Mike Wantuck set still hold, all the records that Mike Lane set while coach, in that pool, are still records.
Howard Baron May 2, 2012 at 07:15 pm
Chris, in your prior postings, you have accused the Board of intentionally withholding sinking funds from Andover in order to justify the building of a new HS, causing the building to be run down and in shambles. Now you're saying that the building as is is great.
So which one is it? I'm confused.
Neal Charness May 2, 2012 at 07:20 pm
Mr. Baron's letter is a very well though out description of the issues before our community. If you are undecided on the bond issuance election please read this letter and Mr. Baron's other posts and compare them to the B2020 claims that isolating the 9th graders at the old building is an "academy" or their flyers sent out saying "nothing is wrong." They have tried to scare voters by describing the bonds as is the cost including interest is the face value of the bond and that a "no" vote would support two "small high schools," when that is totally off the table (the high schools will be consolidated regardless of the vote). Do you believe the well reasoned, thoroughly researched, information provided by Mr. Baron or the misleading, fear inducing, statements by B2020. Unless your agenda is the lowest possible tax bill without regard to the impact on the schools, community, or your property values your choice would seem clear.
Vote YES on May 8.
Timothy May 2, 2012 at 11:40 pm
We need a new pool. Andover's pool broke down half way through the boys season last season, and the boys had to travel to Waterford and use their 12 lane facility. Lahser's pool's electronics all failed at their senior night, delaying the meet, and not making the night as special as the seniors deserved. The air quality in both pools is awful, ask any swimmer who has ever swam in them, they will say it is very hard to breath while swimming. Hosting swim meets can bring in HUGE revenue for the school, you could ask the Birmingham schools how much they make off of the countless number of meets they hold. I believe that repairing our pools will not suffice and be just as costly as building and running one new one. I definitely think that having a beautiful, new pool is a highlight to this new plan and is something we should look forward to.
G.S. May 4, 2012 at 12:56 pm
Chris, your neighbor attended Andover 25-30 years ago. I would hope that *something* had changed in that time and it looked "better" than it did three decades ago. I don't know if smartboards and a new fieldhouse constitutes great improvements though. The classrooms are not equipped with enough outlets to accommodate the growing technological needs, the auditorium is in dire need of renovation...the list goes on. It's much like a car, as some have used this analogy in the past. You can replace parts, get it tuned up, etc. but in the end, it's still going to look and function like an old car and continue to break down. How many times are we going to "update" before it's just more financially beneficial to renovate and rebuild? I think we've reached that time. In fact, I KNOW we have. We have a reasonable plan here, it is affordable for all residents, and it can do nothing but BENEFIT our kids and our community. After all, how many BH residents are driving old, beat up cars that are breaking down on the side of the road? Our community and our kids deserve better.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something